This comparison focuses on two of the most popular super clone watches in the Submariner lineup,
the Clean Factory and VS Factory versions of the 116610LV Hulk.
Verdict First: Two Different Interpretations of the Same Benchmark
The comparison between Clean Factory and VS Factory Submariner Hulk 116610LV replicas is no longer about identifying a clear winner. Instead, it reflects two distinct approaches to replicating one of the most recognizable green dial dive watches ever produced.
Both factories operate at a level where structural accuracy, material choice, and finishing consistency are no longer the primary differentiators. The differences are now concentrated in proportions, tone calibration, and micro-level execution. For most buyers, the decision comes down to preference rather than objective superiority.
At a Glance: Clean vs VS Factory Positioning
- Best for Dial Brightness: Clean Factory 116610LV
- Best for Bezel Accuracy: VS Factory 116610LV
- Best Crown Proportion: VS Factory
- Best Overall Finishing Balance: Close match
- Best for Visual Authenticity (Subjective): Depends on lighting preference
Case Construction and Overall Proportions
Both watches are produced using 904L stainless steel and follow the same nominal dimensions. In hand, the case finishing quality is nearly indistinguishable, especially when considering brushing transitions and edge geometry. These aspects are explained further in our case and finishing analysis. Brushing transitions, lug symmetry, and case edge definition are executed at a consistently high level on both pieces.
However, visual perception tells a slightly different story. The VS Factory version appears marginally larger. This is not due to actual case dimensions but rather bezel coverage and edge geometry.
When examining the bezel edge around the “20” marker, the VS bezel extends slightly further outward, visually increasing the footprint of the watch. This subtle difference influences wrist presence more than expected.
Bezel Structure and Tooth Geometry
The bezel is one of the most discussed differences between Clean and VS versions. While both are ceramic inserts with engraved numerals, the edge teeth reveal a more noticeable variation.
Clean Factory uses a slightly softer tooth profile, with rounded edges and less aggressive depth. VS Factory, on the other hand, produces sharper, more defined teeth that feel closer to original machining standards.
From a purely structural standpoint, VS appears to prioritize edge clarity, while Clean focuses on visual smoothness. Which is closer to genuine specifications depends on how strictly one evaluates tactile versus visual cues.
Crown Design and Case Integration
Crown shape is often overlooked, but here it becomes one of the more noticeable differences. Clean’s crown is slimmer, with tighter proportions relative to the crown guards. VS adopts a fuller crown profile, giving it a more substantial presence.
Functionally, both operate on the same internal structure due to identical movement architecture. The difference is purely external, yet it significantly affects perceived authenticity depending on reference comparison standards.
Dial Color and Bezel Tone Differences
Color calibration is where these two factories diverge most clearly, particularly in dial texture and printing consistency. You can read more in our dial analysis. The Hulk’s identity is defined by its green tone, and each factory interprets this differently.
Clean Factory leans toward a brighter, more vibrant green, especially noticeable under direct light. VS Factory opts for a deeper, more subdued green, which can appear more consistent under varying lighting conditions.
The bezel insert follows the same pattern. Clean appears slightly greener, while VS maintains a more neutral tone. The pearl marker also differs subtly, with VS presenting a slightly whiter appearance.
Bracelet and First Link Transition
At first glance, the bracelet construction is nearly identical. Link spacing, brushing consistency, and articulation feel consistent across both versions.
Closer inspection reveals differences in the first link connection to the case. The curvature and elevation vary slightly, affecting how the bracelet flows from the lugs.
These differences are subtle but can influence comfort and visual continuity when worn.
Clasp and Engraving Details
Clasp construction shows minimal variation in structure, but engraving details differ. Clean and VS use different internal codes, which are visible upon inspection.
The engraving depth and alignment are both well executed, though minor font differences can be observed under magnification.
Case Back and External Finishing
The case back remains consistent in overall design. Differences here are minimal and largely limited to finishing nuances rather than structural changes.
Movement Comparison: Same Base With Minor Execution Differences
Both Clean and VS versions use the Dandong 3135 movement, which follows a similar architecture used in many high-end super clone watches. You can explore a more detailed breakdown in our movement analysis., which has become the standard for high-end 116610LV replicas.
Mechanically, the movements are identical in architecture and performance expectations. The differences are limited to engraving details and finishing variations.
VS includes additional engraved codes between screws, while Clean maintains a cleaner plate surface. These distinctions do not affect performance but may influence perceived authenticity for detail-focused collectors.
Which One Is Closer to Genuine?
There is no universal answer. Clean Factory provides a brighter, more visually striking interpretation that aligns well with certain lighting conditions. VS Factory emphasizes structural sharpness and deeper color consistency.
The choice depends on what aspect of the original watch is prioritized—color vibrancy or proportional realism.
Testing Context and Evaluation Approach
All observations in this comparison are based on side-by-side physical inspection under identical lighting conditions. No digital enhancement or color correction has been applied to the images. The goal is to reflect real-world perception rather than controlled studio output.
Choosing Between Clean and VS
If you prefer brighter dial tones and a more vibrant visual presence, Clean Factory is the better choice.
If you prioritize sharper bezel structure and more consistent proportions, VS Factory may feel closer to the genuine watch.
You can view available models here:
Clean Factory Submariner Hulk
VS Factory Submariner Hulk
